The boys took the stage Tuesday night. And American Idol's Top 12 girls took the stage last night in their first attempt to break an Idol drought. Yep! It's been five years since Jordin Sparks took the Idol crown . . . and a girl hasn't won since. So, did this year's batch of hopefuls live up to the hype? Our American Idol expert, Steve Thompson, shares his thoughts and ranks the contestants from 12th to 1st!